Northwest Payment Brokers
Outgrowing Square

Square Alternatives: 8 Options Worth a Look

The best Square alternatives are Clover, Helcim, Stripe, Toast, Shopify POS, Lightspeed, Material and KwickPOS, and the right one depends on what you sell. Most owners start looking once their card sales pass about $20,000 a month, because a flat rate costs more as you grow. This page shows who each one fits, how each one charges, and how Square and Clover compare. Want the math on your own numbers? Send us one statement.

Why owners look for a Square alternative

Square is a great way to start. You sign up in minutes and sell the same day. The trouble shows up later, as sales grow.

  • The rate stays flat. You pay the same percent on a cheap debit card as on a costly rewards card. At low volume that is fine. At $20,000 to $200,000+ a month, it adds up.
  • Holds and freezes. Fast signup means less checking up front. So the checking happens later, by algorithm, sometimes on a Friday.
  • The hardware stays with Square. Leave, and your devices do not come with you.
  • Square sets your rate. There is no one to bid against it.

8 Square alternatives, by who they fit

1. Best for: Counters that want more devices and apps

Clover

Clover is a family of checkout systems owned by Fiserv: the Station, Mini and Flex, plus apps from its App Market. It can keep taking cards offline when Offline Payments is on. Your rate depends on who sets up the account, so it can be shopped. See our Clover system page.

2. Best for: Owners who want a clear rate and do it all online

Helcim

Helcim uses interchange plus pricing and shows its margin. It charges no monthly fee, you can leave any time, and its rate drops on its own as volume grows. Setup and support happen online. Read how we stack up against Helcim.

3. Best for: Online stores and apps with a developer

Stripe

Stripe suits businesses that sell through their own app or website, and its tools for coders are some of the best. If most of your sales happen in person, card-present pricing usually costs less. Read our Stripe match-up.

4. Best for: Restaurants that want one bundle

Toast

Toast is made for restaurants. Its card processing is locked to Toast while you use the system, and its rates are quoted per merchant, not posted. Bring a quote and compare it. See the Toast comparison.

5. Best for: Shops that already sell on Shopify

Shopify POS

It keeps the store and the website on one stock list. Its card rate is a listed flat rate, the same style as Square. Our Material page has it side by side with other retail systems.

6. Best for: Larger retail with deep stock lists

Lightspeed

Lightspeed is strong on stock and loyalty. Like Shopify POS, it lists a flat card rate on its own payments. Check its plan price with add-ons before you compare.

7. Best for: Boutiques and independent retail

Material

Material is one $99 a month plan with loyalty, texting and QuickBooks Online on it. Card processing sits outside that price, so the rate behind it can be bid. Read the Material system page.

8. Best for: Restaurants that cannot go down

KwickPOS

KwickPOS runs in the cloud but keeps a true local mode when the internet drops. Its hardware is not tied to one card company, so your rate stays yours to shop. See the KwickPOS page.

How each option sets your card rate

Your system is the screen your staff uses. Your rate is what each sale costs you. This table shows how each option sets the rate.

OptionHow card fees are setCan you shop the rate?
SquareOne flat rate on every saleNo. Square sets it.
CloverDepends on who sets up the accountYes, if you set it up through someone who shops it
HelcimInterchange plus, margin shownVolume discounts apply on their own
StripeFlat rate, priced for onlineMostly at large volume
ToastQuoted per merchantOnly inside Toast
Shopify POSListed flat rateNot on its own payments
LightspeedListed flat rateNot on its own payments
MaterialSoftware plan, processing apartYes
KwickPOSSoftware plan, processing apartYes

When the system and the card account are kept apart, you can change one without losing the other. Many owners leave Square for that reason. Our interchange plus guide explains the pricing most shops move to.

Square vs Clover, head to head

These two get compared the most, so here they are side by side.

  • Hardware. Square sells the Register, Handheld, Terminal, Stand and Kiosk, plus small add-ons for tap, chip and swipe. Clover sells the Station, Station Duo, Mini, Flex and Kiosk.
  • Software. Square bundles its own apps. Clover adds outside apps through its App Market, for things like loyalty, online ordering and QuickBooks.
  • Pricing. Square posts its plans and says they start at $0. Clover's price depends on the devices and software plan you pick, and on who sets up the account.
  • Who sets the rate. With Square, Square does. With Clover, it depends on how you buy it. Our Clover direct comparison explains the difference.
  • Leaving. Square hardware works only with Square. Clover bought direct can carry a rate you cannot bargain and a plan you do not use.

We sell Clover, so you should know that. We will still tell you straight when Square is the better start. Our Square comparison does the same.

When Square is still the right call

  • You are just starting, or your card sales are under about $20,000 a month.
  • You want to take cards today, with no setup visit.
  • You like one company for the software, the devices and the help.

If that is you, stay put for now. Check your real rate again when sales grow.

How to leave Square without a mess

  1. Export your item list and customer list from Square first.
  2. Pick the new system and get the card account approved before you cancel anything.
  3. Plan for new devices, since Square hardware does not carry over.
  4. Pick a slow day to go live. Run a test sale, a refund and a tip.
  5. Keep Square open for a few weeks for refunds on old sales.

Our full guide on how to switch card processing companies covers the rest, step by step.

What to ask any company before you sign

  1. What is the full fee on a card sale, and what is the monthly software fee?
  2. Is there a contract or a cancel fee?
  3. Do I own the device, or am I renting it?
  4. How fast do I get paid, and what can hold up my money?
  5. Who do I call when something breaks?
  6. Can I run a fee program like dual pricing, and who sets it up?

Where our team helps

We are a Federal Way team that has worked with local shops since 2010. You keep the system you like, and we work on the card account underneath it. We shop your card fees, match the software plan to your business and set up the devices in person.

Not sure which system fits? Browse our point-of-sale systems by trade.

Square alternative questions

What is the best alternative to Square?

It depends on how you sell. Counters that want more devices often pick Clover. Restaurants look at Toast or KwickPOS. Retail looks at Material, Shopify POS or Lightspeed. Online sellers look at Stripe. Owners who want a clear rate look at Helcim.

Is there a cheaper option than Square?

At small volume, Square's flat rate is hard to beat for ease. Past about $20,000 a month, a bid on your real numbers often costs less. One month of statements shows the gap.

Can I switch from Square to Clover?

In many cases, yes. Catalogs and customers move where the systems allow. Square hardware does not carry over, so plan on new devices.

Does Clover work offline?

Clover can keep taking cards offline when its Offline Payments setting is on. Those sales go through once you are back online.

Do I need a contract to leave Square?

Square's pricing page says it has no locked-in contracts. For the next system, ask about the length of the deal and any cancel fee before you sign.

Why did Square hold my money?

Apps that approve you in minutes can also hold or freeze funds, and an algorithm makes that call. An account that is checked up front by a person is less likely to surprise you.

Get a second look at your Square statement

Send one recent statement and we'll put a bid beside it. Call (253) 336-6321 or request your free statement review.

Want this done for you, free?

Send one statement. Plain-English answer in 24 hours.